As-Salaamu ‘Alaykum,
Al-Hamdu li Llaah. May Allah send blessings and greetings upon the Messenger of Allah, his people, and his Companions…
I feel blessed to provide for you this translation of the explanation of al-’Imaam ‘Ibn Hajar al-’Asqalaanee on the narration in Saheeh al-Bukhaaree of ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, kissing and speaking to the Black Stone.
Since I am not anywhere near qualified to give my own opinions about this matter, I shall let the ‘Imaam speak for himself…
Fath al-Baaree by ‘Ibn Hajar al-’Asqalaanee
Mujallad III Suffahaat 462-463
There is mentioned in this chapter a narration of ‘Umar about kissing the Stone, and his statement: ‘…you do not harm, and do not benefit’ as though it had not been proven to him any conditions other than that.
And indeed narrations are mentioned about it:
A narration of ‘Abd Allah bin ‘Amriw bin al-’Aas, Marfuu’:
‘Indeed the Stone and the Station (of ‘Ibraaheem) are two jewels from the jewels of al-Jannah, Allah suppressing the Nuur from them, and if He did not do that, truly they would illuminate all that is between the East and the West’…
It came out from ‘Ahmad and at-Tirmithee; and ‘Ibn Hibbaan declared it authentic. And in its’ chain is Rujaa’ ‘Abu Yahyaa, and he is weak. At-Tirmithee said: a strange narration (Ghareeb), and it was transmitted on authority of ‘Abd Allah bin ‘Amriw severed (Mawquuf).
And ‘Ibn ‘Abee Haatim said, on authority of his father: ‘it more closely resembles being discontinued, and he who raises it does not (do so) with strength’. Read more »